Alice Designs the one stop shop for newsletter design
 
0118 958 5520

Paper versus electronic newsletters

back button

about the purpose of a newsletter

find out about newsletter content part 1

find out about newsletter content part 2

using white space

what makes a good newsletter

newsletter mistakes and how  to avoid them

go ask Alice contact link

The rise of the e-newsletter has occurred due to increases in technology and our busy professional lifestyles. Sending emails is relatively inexpensive and with the use of autoresponders and other software can be cost effective in building up databases of potential audiences for specific marketing purposes. How they are produced will depend on their target audience, the subject matter and method of publication due to flexibility and availability.

Before you assume they will overtake the need for paper newsletters, take time to consider these advantages of the paper newsletter, but also bear in mind that each kind of newsletter is valid for their own potential readership:

First impressions
Think of a morning email in-box full of both relevant and junk mail, in which somewhere lies an e-newsletter. Unless the reader has plenty of time or goes systematically through their mail, and unless the title of the e-newsletter is immediately catchy, relevant or mind-blowing, it probably will be filed away for later or become swamped amongst other more pressing material. How likely is it to be opened and read immediately? Would it be scanned for relevant content which would grab the reader’s attention and demand action?

Consider the paper post the same morning. If the paper newsletter is a self mailer, it won’t be concealed away inside an envelope. Even if it isn’t immediately read there and then, it will noted and put aside, but the colour of the paper or design of the nameplate will contribute towards its visibility amongst the other papers by enticing further consideration, even if it is later at coffee time or going home on the train.

Content over matter
How easily readable is your e-newsletter? Ideally it should be short and snappy, not long and cumbersome. E-newsletters should be by nature brief and immediate. Does it contain suitable links to encourage further reading and does the front page

 

 

enable you to open up other pages to continue the articles? Is it easy to read on-screen or is a paper copy more accessible? Would you be forced to print it off anyway, especially if you wanted to file it away for reference purposes?

A paper newsletter contains more information in further detail and with relevant graphics. It isn’t necessarily designed for quick absorption of an idea, concept or promotion, but for more developed reasoning and an increase in content to be read at leisure. Arguments and objectives can be explored, as well as appropriate research and suitable examples, and each issue can be filed away for reference or bound in yearly volumes for archives.

Reception party
E-newsletters can be so easily or accidentally deleted or eliminated by over-zealous spam-filters. They depend on their readers being on-line and willing to confirm their subscription. Paper newsletters will always be delivered to an address as long as it is correct, and because of their design, size and content tend to command more respect, probably because of the nature of their subscription. They may acquire an airing on the coffee table or a slot in the to-read-later file, and will probably be read by a larger, more inopportune, audience.

In defence of the e-newsletter, it does have the advantage that it is relatively inexpensive to send, the delivery is almost immediate and receipt, opening and click rates are trackable for marketing purposes. A quick response is measurable through clicks and comments in return emails. The paper newsletter relies on the postal service and has no way of tracing whether it is correctly received and read by the right person, unless a response or call to action is taken up. Costs for production can be offset by advertising revenue, but this is only appropriate for regularly published newsletters to a recognised subscription base.